Monday, April 23, 2007

Misreading Rock Lyrics:

Some elitists scoff at the notion that any serious poetry can be found in rock lyrics. Well, some, arguably most rock lyrics are bad. But given the quantity of rock music, even if say 5% is good, there are a lot of "diamonds" in the "dunghill," as Jefferson would put it.

That doesn't mean that the average listener appreciates the message (or even knows the right lyrics!).

Especially with songs about America, American listeners are probably likely to assume an "up with America" message when a typical rock artist who may be cut from bohemian cloth, is likely not to impart that message. Most notably, Ronald Reagan misunderstood Bruce Springsteen's "Born in the USA" which is not an "up with America" song. Neil Young's Rockin' in the Free World folks may wrongly assume has pro-America lyrics but does not.

Black Sabbath's War Pigs has profoundly anti-war lyrics, yet many of the young metal-heads listening to the music are likely to take it as a pro-war song. During the first gulf war, the young rebels in the audience would scream things like "yeah, fuck Iraq!" and Ozzy would be like, "that's not what the song is about." Indeed, Zakk Wylde -- Ozzy's guitarist -- comes from that New Jersey metal-head blue collar, sort of northern redneck, culture (in PA, it's the Alabama between Philadelphia and Pittsburgh) and is pro-war, unlike that old hippie Ozzy (isn't it cool that rockers in the same band can reasonably disagree on politics).

Kansas' "Song for America" likewise has "down with America" lyrics (but set to an upbeat tune). As a longtime fan, I've noticed many fans don't get the lyrics and the band, during the live shows, plays along and pretends it's a patriotic song! The following YouTube clip of the entire song perfectly illustrates this. The entire song is played to the picture of a waiving American flag. If you've never heard the song, it's one of the best composed, best sung progressive rock tunes, up there with the best of Yes, Genesis, and Rush.



The lyrics are reproduced below. They were written in the early 1970s and the writer, Kerry Livgren, was no doubt inspired by the hippie movement, whose critique of America and "back to nature" sentiments trace back to Rousseau. The lyrics in the song are reminiscent of Rousseau's critique of Locke.

Virgin land of forest green, dark and stormy plains, here all life abounds
Sunlit valley, mountain fields, unseen in the rain, here all life abounds
No man rules this land, no human hand has soiled this paradise
Waiting patiently, so much to see, so rich in Earth's delights

Painted desert, sequined sky, stars that fill the night, here all life abounds
Rivers flowing to the sea, sunshine pure and bright, here all life abounds
No man rules this land, no human hand has soiled this paradise
Waiting patiently, so much to see, so rich in Earth's delights

So the maiden lies in waiting, for the sails to reach the shore
Land of beauty and abundance, innocent, you opened wide your door
Wanderers found the waiting treasure, full of gifts beyond their measure
Milk and honey for our pleasure.....

Across the sea there came a multitude, sailing ships upon the wave
Filled with visions of Utopia, and the freedom that they crave
Ravage, plunder, see no wonder, rape and kill and tear asunder
Chop the forest, plow it under.....

Highways scar the mountainsides, buildings to the sky, people all around
Houses stand in endless rows, sea to shining sea, people all around
So we rule this land, and here we stand upon our paradise,
Dreaming of a place, our weary race is ready to arise


This is certainly not in praise of America's manifest destiny!

4 comments:

Tom Van Dyke said...

God, I hate hippies.

Now THIS is a good song.

Jonathan said...

Loved that movie. I was quite amused by the sex scene in the unrated version. Very few things surprise me; that did.

Deep Thapa said...

credit reports online internet credit reports online credit history credit history online internet credit reports internet credit report credit history online credit history online online credit history credit history online internet credit report credit history online internet credit report internet credit reports

Deep Thapa said...

Consumer Credit Report Consumer Credit Debt Report Free Federal Credit Report Free Copy Of Credit Report Sample Credit Report Consumer Report On Credit Counseling Servicesv Internet Credit Report Fake Credit Report Credit Fir.Blogspot.Com Free Report Government Free Credit Report Cic Triple Advantage Credit Report Credit Report Dispute Copy Of Credit Report Cic Credit Report Credit Card Report 81.9.3.77 Credit Qq Report Results.Php Debt Consolidation Credit Report 2006 Credit November Report Account Credit Limitation Report Settled Statute Fix Bad Credit Report Repair Countrywide Credit Report Credit Eliminating From Negative Report Credit Report From Credit History Report Credit Report Rating Consumer Credit Free Online Report Vacuum Credit In Mississippi Report Sol Credit Report Employment Background Check Consumer Report Credit Record Yahoo Free Credit Report Credit Report Services Order Credit Report Company Credit Report Online Canadian Credit Report Consumer Credit Free Report Services Trans Union Employment Credit Report Expedia Credit Report Credit Report Advice internet credit reports .com annual credit report .com credit free report .com credit report 1 3 credit free in report 100 credit free report 3 bureau credit report 3 credit report 3 credit reports 3 in 1 credit report absolutely credit free report advantage cic credit report triple agency credit report all credit reports annual com credit report annual credit first other report services annual credit free government report annual credit free online report annual credit free report annual credit report arizona credit free report bad credit fix repair report bad credit item remove report bureau credit free report bureau credit report bureau credit report three business credit report canada credit free in report canada credit free report canada credit report canadian credit free report canadian credit report card consolidation credit credit debt report resource card credit credit free no report card credit credit free no report required card credit credit free report without card credit report cheap credit report check credit check credit free online report score check credit free report check credit history check credit rating check credit report cic credit report clean credit report up com credit free report com credit report consumer credit report copy credit free report copy credit report credit bureau report credit check credit check online credit debt effect report settlement credit deleted from have item report credit delinquent does long report stay credit dispute report credit does it long report stay credit equifa report credit equifax free online report credit equifax free report credit equifax online report credit equifax report credit experian free report credit experian report credit federal free report credit fix report credit fixing report repossession credit free get report credit free government report credit free instant online report credit free instant report credit free new report york credit free one report time credit free online report credit free report credit free report score credit free report totally credit free report trans union credit free report trw credit free report yearly credit get report credit government report credit history credit history online credit information report credit instant online report credit instant report credit landlord report credit lien long report stay tax credit line report credit line report seasoned trade credit monitoring report credit national report credit online report