I think I missed
this when it was posted in 2014. A taste:
This is an impassioned book about the Declaration of Independence. It
comes from specific personal and pedagogical experiences, as its
author, a classicist and political theorist at Princeton, winsomely
reports.
Danielle Allen employs several techniques, some old, some new, in
engaging and expositing her book’s central object: what she calls a
close, “sentence by sentence” reading of the document, one that
sometimes lingers over the meaning of a single term but that also draws
upon modern theories of the uses to which language can be put. But while
the methods are specific, the aim is quite grand and ambitious: to make
the Declaration “our Declaration,” with “us” being not just all
Americans, of whatever race or socioeconomic condition, but all
humanity.
The Declaration has stirred Allen mightily. She describe teaching it
as a transformative experience, and she has responded with all of her
being, as a scholar, a citizen, and a human being. This is engaged
scholarship in a fulsome sense.
Our Declaration: A Reading of the Declaration of Independence in Defense of Equality is also clearly conceived and written. ...
It even mentions our friend Gregg Frazer's book:
Like many today, she wants her egalitarianism to rest on a secular
foundation. This, one suspects, is the deeper meaning of her oft-used
term, “commitment,” which is what human beings do when they cannot
affirm a principle on the basis of either faith or reason. Certainly,
the naturalistic egalitarian anthropology she teases out of the text is
more sketched than demonstrated, and with significant lacunae. For a
better treatment of the character of the deity affirmed in the
Declaration, one should consult Gregg L. Frazer’s The Religious Beliefs of America’s Founders
(2012) and his useful concept of “theistic rationalism,” halfway
between Deism and 18th century Christian orthodoxy. Allen gets close,
but her manner of reading precludes her from considering, in a
comprehensive view, the Declaration’s teaching about the deity.
Also
check out this comment at the bottom by W.B. Allen who is, I'm pretty sure, Danielle's distinguished father. He swings to the Right; she swings to the Left.
No comments:
Post a Comment